So I've been thinking A LOT about Greg's post regarding home schooling in California. I don't know if it has to do with me being at home and with me actively "teaching" E every day ... It could be. Regardless, I've been thinking a lot about the post and I revised some of my thoughts.
Originally, I was struck by how similar this sounded to the political education that was conducted under Nazi and communist regimes. And on those grounds, I rejected some of the statements made by the judge.
But having taken a bit more time to think about it, I realize that my earlier post was ill-thought out and more than just a touch niave. After all, apart from the subjects of math and perhaps grammer (although that is somewhat debatable), everything that is taught is taught from a point of view. One of the major faults underlying the Enlightenment Project was a belief in the objectively neutral party. There is no such thing. Literature is taught from a point of view. History is taught from a point of view. Heck, even geography is taught from a point of view (e.g. Who owns the Golan Heights?) If you wish to debate this, please feel free to do so. Just please don't do it under this thread because I don't want you to miss the point of what I saying here.
So, I think what I actually was reacting to was not the premise itself. It was the practical application of the premise. I don't want a liberalized government that is pro-naturalism (with all of the consequent positions in terms of sexual identity, drugs, political philosophy, religious philosophy, etc...) deciding what can and cannot be taught to my child. I want to make that decision.
So for instance, when it comes to teaching about patriotism, loyalty to government, etc..., I am not against teaching those things. But I want to teach them within a Christian worldview. In other words, democracy may be the best of all possible political ideologies, but it does not address our obligation to the poor who will always be with us (Deut 15:11). Loyalty to government is scriptural (Matt. 22:21), but only to the point where it does not interfere with the precepts of God.
I could go on, but I think I've made my point. Back off Big Government and give me the right to educate my child as I see fit.